The Newcastle United Blog

News and Commentary On Newcastle United By Ed Harrison, A Proud Exiled Geordie And Lifelong Fan

The Newcastle United Blog header image 2
Banner created by Reilly - one of our readers
Howay The Lads!!



This Was McClaren´s Biggest Blunder In The Summer

8:44 am, Wednesday, December 2nd, 2015 by Dr. Ed Harrison · 6 Comments

Even though he was nowhere near Newcastle fanss´ choice of a new manager when Steve McClaren arrived in June there was some positive vibes about Newcastle and the fans seemed willing to support Steve and give him a chance.

We had only just survived a terrible second half of the season under John Carver and we had survived – if only just – but now we had a chance to put things right – and that nonsense of last season wouldn´t happen again.

You learn from your mistakes.

Let´s rephrase that – smart people learn from their mistakes otherwise history repeats itself.

Fabricio Coloccini West+Ham+United+v+Newcastle+PEIDveRfM1Cl

Fabricio Coloccini – having a poor season – no leadership

And there were some decent buys made in the summer and over £52M was the biggest outlay of transfer funds in our history – so there was a certain expectancy from Newcastle fans.

But who would have thought in early December we would be second bottom of the league in what is the worst start in Newcastle’s long history and 4 points worse than our start in our relegation season seven years ago.

It´s 10 points from 14 games and some terrible performance – but none worse than the last two when some Newcastle players didn´t seem to want to be playing.

Iconic  former stars like Alan Shearer have come out blasted the players – and blasted the transfer strategy that has never worked in the past to build a top team – but the powers that be stick with it.

But when you look back in hindsight over what happened in the summer the single biggest mistake Steve made was to rely on and put his trust in Fabricio Coloccini and also give him a one-year extension to his contract.

McClaren made a huge thing of it in the week before our first game against Southampton.

And Coloccini had not played one minute of pre-season football in the summer, but he was still paired with new signing Chancel Mbemba in central defense against the Saints.

Coloccini has blown hot and cold throughout the season – and mostly (very) cold in the last couple of games.

He just doesn´t seem to have the necessary leadership skills at a time when we need somebody with the spirit, verve and drive of a Kevin Nolan to shake players out of their sleep.

McClaren´s faith in Coloccini also meant we didn´t bring in a top center-back to replace him last summer – and Steve will probably be regretting that now since our defense is simply hopeless.

We were linked with a number of good center-backs over the summer including Joel Matip of Schalke and he would have cost less than the £12M we shelled out for Florian Thauvin – one of Graham Carr´s favorite players.

The Newcastle defense is not good enough for the Premier League and we´ve conceded 30 goals in 14 games – on track to concede 81 goals this season.

We have averaged conceding 63 goals over the last three seasons – one of the worst defensive records of any club in the Premier League.

So why haven´t we fixed that problem?

Graham Carr brings in the players and there seems little to no consultation with the manager on who he wants or needs.

That´s one big reason Alan Pardew left the club rather hastily late last year and he has full control at Crystal Palace and he´s doing extremely well this season.

That should be a hint to the powers that be at Newcastle, but they may not listen.

They want to be right about what they are doing and seemingly will not allow anything like facts to get in the way of what they are doing.

That stupidity could see Newcastle relegated in May and let´s hope we don´t see more young players in January who could be good for us in a couple of years,

We need experienced players now if we are going to survive.

Comments welcome.



Tags: Newcastle News




6 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Lilongwe Geordie // Dec 2, 2015 at 8:49 AM

    Lilongwe Geordie // Dec 2, 2015 at 8:48 AM – Repost with link……

    BandB,
    Look up more on the Lazio fans. They have been protesting and boycotting for a while now.

    http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/26509338

    This article is from when it started. There average attendance this season is 13,000 lower than last season. There highest attendance of the season so far is 7,000 lower then their average last season.

    Yes, the derby saw Roma fans boycott against the security measures, but the Lazio fans have been boycotting far longer, and have had no impact so far.

  • 2 nut meg // Dec 2, 2015 at 9:09 AM

    Collo seems to have a really strong hold over NUFC. Anybody have any idea as to what it could be? On target to concede 81 goals this season eh,is this the trophy Ashley was talking about….most goals conceded ?

  • 3 BandB // Dec 2, 2015 at 9:15 AM

    Lil,

    So far.
    But as the coach says, it can’t go on forever. And they aren’t in relegation trouble.
    Perhaps Ashley is just such a one-off that he laughs gleefully at TV images of people streaming out of a stadium with his logo splashed all over it.
    As I’ve said before, the idea that Ashley sneers in the face of danger should have died the day he employed a crisis management guru. And even that is a game of diminishing returns.

  • 4 ToonTiger // Dec 2, 2015 at 9:21 AM

    He wasn’t allowed to bring in a cb. Ashleech effectively told him Colo was staying and to use him. Colo is an Ashley man.

  • 5 lesh // Dec 2, 2015 at 9:32 AM

    Not sure if it was really McClaren’s choice to extend Colo’s contract. Given the tight wads and the fact Charnley and Carr had blown what was probably their budget, I’d say that extending Colo’s stay was foisted onto McClaren.

    Of course McC would make a big thing over Colo’s extension, he’s clearly professional in his ways and slamming it wouldn’t happen!

    Place the onus for not signing a proven CB firmly onto the shoulders of Carr and Charnley- not McClaren.

  • 6 firebug666 // Dec 2, 2015 at 9:38 AM

    Colo is Ashley’s eye and ears inside the club, of that I have no doubt.




previous post: I´m Happy At Newcastle And Cannot Ask For Anything Else

next post: Pardew Knew Exactly How To Smash Newcastle