The Newcastle United Blog

News and Commentary On Newcastle United By Ed Harrison, A Proud Exiled Geordie And Lifelong Fan

The Newcastle United Blog header image 2
Howay The Lads!!

Benitez Asked To Stay If Newcastle Relegated

10:55 am, Saturday, March 26th, 2016 by Dr. Ed Harrison · 8 Comments

It seems the Board Director Bob Moncur tried to get Rafa Benitez to commit long term to Newcastle even if we are relegated in May, but Rafa Benitez would not commit to that – although he didn’t say he wouldn’t stay either.

That’s the big question at Newcastle, although of course if we stay up that’s the best scenario of all.

The second best scenario is we take the plunge but Rafa commits say to one season down below – but it’s almost certain he could get us straight back up because a lot of our good players would then be willing to stay with Rafa.

The worst scenario is we go down and he leaves – and that’s going to be very hard to take for the fans – it will be heart-break time on Tyneside.


Bob Moncur – tried to get Rafa to fully commit to Newcastle

This is what Bob has said today in the Scotsman in a very long interview where he talks about the various aspects of his life as a footballer:

“I was trying to get him to commit to the club long-term.” “Everyone expects him to leave if we get relegated but I told him he was the future.”

“He could re-build us and hopefully make us great again.” “I told him I was speaking on behalf of all the fans, those poor, long-suffering folk who sing Blaydon Races in all weathers.”

“I got quite emotional as I was speaking to him and could feel myself welling up.” “That happens more since my cancer.” “I like Rafa.” “He’s a football man, very sincere, and he looks you straight in the eye.”

“I told him it would reflect well on him if he didn’t just walk away.” “But I couldn’t quite get the answer I was looking for, other than: ‘Bob, we won’t be relegated.’”

“I told him that impressed me, although had to add that I’ve seen more of this team than him and know what they can be like.“ “Plus, I’m a dour Scotsman who tends to look on the black side.”

We can fully understand why Rafa doesn’t want to talk about what would happen if we do go down, because he’s trying to get everybody to believe and support the fact we can stay up – which is possible.

And it’s a huge leverage too for Rafa to have everybody try their very best and do everything possible this season to save Newcastle – given that he may just walk out in May – which is his right via the clause in his contract.

And it cannot hurt if Rafa sees 52,000 screaming Geordies at each of the five home games – plus a sold-out contingent of fans at our remaining away games.

But one way to make it worthwhile for Rafa if we go down is he will have lost out on a £2M bonus.

So make that bonus available if he can get us promoted next season – and of course keep his wages and those of his staff at their current levels.

That would keep the fans fully involved and season tickets would sell quickly too.

He could also be persuaded that his win rate could take a nice little hike in the Championship.


And of course he could form the basis of the team while down below, so we’d be in really good position for the following season – always assuming we get promoted straight back to the Premier League.

And he could start sorting out and reorganizing the club from top to bottom – which is desperately needed – and there’s a lot of work there for Rafa.

We could be in much better condition when we return to the Premier League.

But as we said – he’s completely committed to staying up – and so is everybody associated with Newcastle – we can do it.

But Bob Moncur is also right – Rafa Benitez is the future of Newcastle.

Comments welcome.

Tags: Coaching · Management · Newcastle News · Other News · Prayer · Premier League

8 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Essex Geordie Bill // Mar 26, 2016 at 11:03 AM

    I’m not so sure that that was good PR, he might well look at Moncur rambling into his face and wonder WTF I’m doing here. Still kudos to Bob for trying!!

  • 2 lesh // Mar 26, 2016 at 11:08 AM

    Moncur’s not the one to be trying to tempt Rafa to stay if we’re relegated – it needs Ashley to persuade him with guarantees of ambition for success, total control of footballing matters and sufficient funds to restructure the squad and backroom operations.

    Oh, and provide him of evidence that he wants to realise the Club’s potential by appointing a Chief Exec who shares that ambition – not the servile sycophant that is Charnley!

  • 3 lesh // Mar 26, 2016 at 11:16 AM

    Moncur’s realised that fans have lost confidence in him ss he’s clearly associated with Ashley.

    It’s a bit late to be speaking on behalf of the fans, he should have been more vociferous in speaking out against the shortsightedness and naivety as demonstrated by Ashkey, Charnley and Carr.

    The best thing he could do would be to try to persuade Ashley to invest a commitment to success and then he might have more credibility among the fans.

    Get a grip Bobby, show you can be the star you once were!

  • 4 hibbitt // Mar 26, 2016 at 11:46 AM

    moncur was saying this to any one that would listen last sunday but said the board thought he would stay whats changed in a week

  • 5 The overrated Frenchman // Mar 26, 2016 at 12:02 PM

    Moncur has been an Uncle Tom to the Ashley regime it’s true, but I think his feelings for the club are genuine, and I expect that would come across to Rafa, which can only be a good thing. What do I know, if truth be told, but I do get the impression at least that Benitez has respect and some admiration for the football culture of Newcastle; the people, the club, the history. I think he would get a kick out of achieving something here if he stays around, so if Bobby can help that cause, good for him.

  • 6 Jib // Mar 26, 2016 at 12:10 PM

    I recommend a full reading without the editing.

  • 7 Jail for Ashley // Mar 26, 2016 at 12:17 PM

    Bob, Bob Bob, what have you cosied up to for your pieces of silver.

  • 8 Jib // Mar 26, 2016 at 12:20 PM

    You’re excused a full reading – Too many long words for you.

previous post: Benitez Talks Of Lessons Learned In Past Relegation Experience

next post: This Player Could Become The Unlikely Hero For Newcastle