web analytics

Ashley Unwilling To Invest To Finish In 7th Place – That Argument Completely Misses The Point

Last season Newcastle finished in 10th place and for the money that Ashley gave Rafa to spend during the season – which was very little – that was an excellent return on investment.

We got £123M back from the Premier League last May – what could be better?

We will not finish as high in the table this season – may be as high as 13th and with one more point than last year – and a win today at Fulham will take us to that 45 points total for the season.

BBC pundit Mark Lawrenson makes the financial case for Mike Ashley that the best Newcastle can expect in the next few years is 7th place in the Premier League.

And therefore why should he go overboard in spending Newcastle’s money for three higher places in the league table than we achieved last year?

Here’s what Mark has said about Rafa’s future at Newcastle:

“The big questions, as ever, for the Magpies are will manager Rafa Benitez stay, and will he get the money that he wants to spend?”

“I think the answers are ‘yes’ and ‘no’ – but he will get some of it, and enough to make some more improvements to his squad.”

“We already know Magpies owner Mike Ashley is never going to splash the cash, because he could give Benitez £100M and he is realistically only going to finish seventh, at best.”

“They are halfway up the table right now, so how many more places up the table are they going to get as a return for his money?”

“That is Ashley’s way of thinking.”

“He is a businessman and Newcastle made an £18.6M profit last season, so he is never going to agree with the fans urging him to spend.”

Mark makes it all about money and the return on that investment – which is exactly how Ashley thinks – but that’s all in the short term.

Let’s not get bogged down in investment and return – Newcastle have the money to spend and currently we have one of the best managers in the business on Tyneside.

And we don’t spend the money we have available to spend on players – that policy must end.

We have to break through from the owner’s self-imposed financial barriers.

Leicester City, after just avoiding relegation on their first season back in the Premier League in 2014-2015 , didn’t have that kind of negative thinking.

After that dodgy first season back they went on to win the PL title for the first time in 2016 with 81 points – 10 points to spare above second-placed Arsenal.

The season before they won the title they finished in 14th place on 41 points – pulling away from the bottom of the table in the last few games of the season – and finished 2 points and one place above a John Carver managed Newcastle.

We believe Rafa thinks if he is given a fair shake in terms of investment – his knowledge of the game and his contacts around the world can get some good players to the cub.

And he can also develop young players coming through the club.

When you stop concentrating on limitations you may have and start with a vision for what you want to achieve  – one of the best teams and clubs in Europe – that’s when miracles begin to happen – and when Newcastle can make rapid progress.

Give Rafa what he needs and then we need to strap on those seat belts.

You don’t make money in football from the profits you may make every financial year – like in a normal business.

You do what Spurs and other clubs have done, and invest in the squad under a top-class manager – and the price of the club will soar.

That’s what Mike Ashley should be doing and not nit-picking all the time with Newcastle’s money.

How Will Newcastle Fare At Fulham?

View Results
Loading ... Loading ...

Comments welcome.

3 comments so far

  • c-dog

    May 12, 2019 at 6:37 AM

    Comment #1

    Should this be Rafa, Rondon & Big Mo’s final involvement at Newcastle, which looks increasingly likely, I hope we give them a fine farewell

  • Nicky the ball tosser

    May 12, 2019 at 8:17 AM

    Comment #2

    I’m sure it is a poor investment to “buy” a team to finish 7th, but you still need to maximize revenues and put the profits back into infrastructure to grow the club, and you do need to provide value for money on the match day ticket Mike Ashley.

  • mfw13

    May 12, 2019 at 6:23 PM

    Comment #3

    It’s a logical argument, because the Premier League doesn’t really reward teams very much for simply moving up the table ($2-3 million bonus per place). The real money is in the Champions League.

    So finishing 7th might earn a club like Newcastle an extra $10-15 million, but would probably cost much more than that to achieve.

    If the Premier League really wants to incentivize clubs, increase the bonuses for finishing higher in the table (to $5 million per place, for example). If 7th got you $50 million more than 17th, then clubs might care.


You must log in to post a comment.